• Testimonials

  • We know you will love Fancy That Cake as much as we do. Katie puts so much time and effort into each of her cakes, and makes each a work of art unique to the customer who orders it. But don’t just take our word for it, see what our customers have to say! Check below to read dozens of testimonials from our wonderful customers!

  • I wanted to let you know that the cakes were perfect. The cookie cake was the highlight of our day especially. Brandon loved it. Was 100% surprised about it being her. It was so realistic our guests thought it was a statue. I didn't cry the entire day till later in the evening when we kinda got a moment alone to look at her. It was perfect! Thank you so much for helping make my day absolutely perfect.

    Danielle S. (June 2014)

  • Your cake was a hit! You may have seen it as one of the prominent pictures from the event in the SEMissourian. We displayed it out where the event was and it was an eye-catching centerpiece to our evening. Your stack of business cards were gone in 10 minutes. People were on their hands and knees looking up under the portico and up close at the authors written on the side. The more we looked, the more impressive your attention to detail became. And to top it all off, it tasted great. We cut 1″ square columns and went through maybe 2/3 of the cake that night. Rest was cut and boxed and put in the fridge in breakroom. It was all gone this morning! Thanks again for squeezing us in and making this very cool cake which became a focal point of our evening celebration.

    David S. (Nov. 2014)

  • Katie is so nice and accommodating! She is open to so many wonderful cake designs and does a beautiful job!

    Bree M. (Nov. 2017)

  • Extremely easy to work with. My wedding cake was beautiful! To top it off- it even tasted amazing- not dried out and flavorless like so many I have had at other weddings. Simply the best!

    Misty D. (June 2015)

  • Katie made our daughter’s 1st birthday cake. It was amazing how much detail there was and that almost all of it was edible! She does beautiful work! It was definitely the fanciest cake (no pun intended) besides hopefully her wedding cake some day that little bit will ever have.

    Casey P. (Nov. 2017)

  • Fancy that Cake made the most amazing, beautiful and absolutely delicious cake for our wedding. So delicious in fact that my sister in law ate 5 pieces. Ha! Seriously people were lining up for cake when they heard about the flavor/filling combos. Everything was perfect. They were also great to work with and super friendly.

    Andrea T. (July 2014)

  • You made my daughter, Jessica and Chuck David's wedding cake, steampunk, it was very good, strawberry and pecan I believe. All the decorations were edible, I would recommend you to anyone for their bakery goods. The cupcakes were awesome too. Kids enjoyed them because they could eat the gears and keys.

    Sandra O. (Aug. 2017)

  • She made my gender reveal baby shower cake and omg it was amazing it looked exactly like the invitations and this year she will be doing my daughters first birthday cake I'm so excited if you order a cake from her you will not be disappointed I promise she has my business from here on out

    Chasity S. (Aug. 2016)

  • Best cake ever. The icing is wonderful. It is sweet, but not " hurt your teeth sweet". She has won us for all our perfect cake buying needs.

    Susie G. (Nov. 2015)

  • We had our wedding cake done my Katie and IT WAS AMAZING!! Looked great and tasted even better. Give it a try, you will love it too!

    Sezgi A. (Oct. 2015)

  • Katie is not only the kindest person to work with, but so incredibly creative, talented and patient in getting your design and every tiny detail just perfect for you! Every cake I see her do is breathtaking! I am amazed at her abilities! Not only is it beautiful to look at but it is absolutely DELICIOUS!! She has so many flavor options and a reasonable timeframe to get it done! We had her do our wedding cake (which was still excellent after her careful freezing instructions when we thawed it and had it on our 1st anniversary) and our son's 1st birthday cake and both turned out absolutely perfect!! So glad we worked with her on those important life events to have the perfect cake to share!! I would HIGHLY recommend Fancy That Cake!

    Rebecca S. (July 2016)

  • She went above and beyond! this cake was like nothing we had ever seen!! its was just breathtaking!!! it was sooooo delicious!! thanks again, Katie for making this special cake a work if meaningful art!! (comment left under photo on Facebook) I cant say enough about Katie! She is a true artist! From the emails to the sketches to the arrival of the cake, it was all perfect! The Custom Harry Potter baby shower cake she did for me was beyond amazing! The detail and amazing "paint" work she did was just too beautiful! Hands down the most amazing cake I have ever seen! She is a wonderful, nice and beyond talented cake master!! (official review on Facebook)

    Marisa C. (Jan 2018)

  • The wedding cake that we ordered was perfection! Not only was it a work of art on the outside, but each layer and flavor was amazing. Thank you for making my daughter's wedding cake all that she wanted and more!!

    Susan K. (Nov. 2017)

  • Excellent baker, creator, designer! My cakes were awesome!!

    Teresa C.

  • Loved the unique retirement cake. It was incredibly delicious as well.

    Deb S.

  • Katie is very talented & her cakes are delicious.

    Tonisha W.

  • Katie is the best! Getting ready to place another order for my daughter's cake!

    Jennifer I-G.

  • Katie was the absolute best to work with! It didn't matter how many times we changed our minds she was patient, gave suggestions, and even sent us pictures to choose from to help us with the process. Our cake was so delicious and our guests loved it! She took the picture and brought it to life. Our cake looked exactly like the picture. It was everything we wanted. Thank you so much Katie!!!

    Tameisha B. (July 2017)

  • My baby shower cake was magnificent and turned out better than I had envisioned. The detail was absolutely flawless!! Amazing cake artistry. (Megan H., mother-to-be) Katie, this was the perfect cake for our Lumberjack Baby Shower! You did an amazing job capturing the theme of the outdoors in this truly awesome cake...such artistic skills! We had lots of ooh's and aah's from the guests as they enjoyed this delicious masterpiece(almost too pretty to cut). Thanks for doing a super job, Katie! (Debbie K., grandmother-to-be) It was the cutest baby shower cake I have ever seen! (Heather M., friend)

    Megan H., Debbie K. and Heather M. (Sept. 2017)

  • Katie did such a wonderful job with the cake we ordered for our coach's retirement party! She was more than happy to work with me when I was trying to decide on size according to our budget! I will definitely be going back to fancy that cake for cakes in the future! Thank you Katie!

    Tara J.

  • Katie made my daughter's wedding cake this past Saturday and it was a hit! The cake was so unique and beautiful as well as delicious! Katie is indeed the artist of cakes. We got so many compliments and the cake made her wedding complete! I highly recommend Katie for cakes for any occasion and I will definitely be ordering from her again!! Very satisfied customer.

    Deborah S.

  • Katie made my cake for my wedding in November and it was amazing. She was easy to work with and was extremely helpful with planning and picking out what I wanted. Thanks for everything! You (and the cake) were awesome!

    Jordi M.

  • Katie always goes above and beyond. She is so easy to work with and has an amazing talent. Thank you so much Katie for making our celebrations special.

    Amy E.

  • Katie made the most adorable and delicious cake for a baby shower this weekend. Honestly we don't know how you did it. Fondant usually isn't that good but yours is delicious. That baby carriage was was perfect. Thanks so much.

    DeAnn W.

  • Thank u so much for making our day so special!!! The cakes were amazing!!! And we got so many compliments!!! Thank u again!!!

    Jana G-B.

  • Katie created beautiful cakes for me and my husband’s wedding reception! She worked with us every step of the way in creating our cakes. I wanted a very unique wedding cake (red and gold!) and Katie more than delivered. I was completely blown away, as were all our guests when they saw it. In addition to my cake being gorgeous, it was also delicious! My husband’s grooms cake was just as awesome! He is a truck driver, as is his brother and so was their dad. He had Katie make a 3D cake of his late dad’s semi truck. It was an amazing cake and a very touching tribute to his dad’s memory. He teared up when Katie delivered the cakes and he saw it for the first time. If you are looking for beautiful/delicious cakes for any occasion, I highly recommend Fancy That Cake!! - A very happy/pleased bride

    Holly R. (Oct. 2017)