Fancy That Cake Testimonials

We know you will love Fancy That Cake as much as we do. Katie puts so much time and effort into each of her cakes, and makes each a work of art unique to the customer who orders it. But don’t just take our word for it, see what our customers have to say! Check below to read dozens of testimonials from our dedicated customers!

Just like last year she gave us exactly what we asked for! Couldn’t be more pleased with her work. Tasted delicious and fondant work was amazing!

Lindsey E.
Oct. 2014
My sisters cake was AMAZING, Breathtaking, gorgeous but even better TASTEFUL!! No words could express how much your talent is appreciated!! Blessings!!

Terunda F.
Sept. 2014
Fancy that cake did an amazing job on my wedding cake and grooms cake. It was a huge hit with everyone!! Very happy with both cakes!! Lets just say it was such a huge hit that there was hardly anything left from either cake.

Maria H.
Oct. 2014
We had so many compliments on the cake and so many people who wanted to know who made it! I hope I bring you in a little bit of business!! Thank you again very much for everything and for working with me on payments. It truly meant a lot. I will definitely be letting you know if I need anything in the future!! The best man was very impressed with the strawberries, I think they were his favorite part!! They looked great!!

Brittany G.
Oct. 2012
Katie…. You completely out done yourself!! Words could never fully express my gratitude… For once I’m lost for words. The venue and planners said “that was the best cake they have EVER seen”. The taste was unbelievable. We only had 3 slices left!! Whatever you do, keep doing it!! How you get a beautiful cake and have it taste so well, is crazy!! You’re the best and I’m honored and so blessed!! Thank You!! Thank you!!

Treneshia F.
Sept. 2014
Katie – I just wanted to send you an email to thank you for such a beautiful cake!!! It was really better than I imagined it to be! You really have a wonderful talent! And the taste was amazing! You had a lot of compliments that day! I told everyone that asked about you so hopefully that will drive a referral some day. Thank you again so very much! I will definitely keep you in mind for future events!!!

Jennifer R.
Feb. 2014
The cake was Amazing!!!!!!!!!!!! I couldn’t be happier! It was the second most talked about subject at the party (first was my baby ). You should have left more cards at the table, everyone wanted your info. We loved the design….still up to 3 am everyone was talking about the cake at home. It tasted great. Thank you so much for the beautiful cakes and helping me make this event memorable. Will definitely do business again.

Saira E.
April 2012
I contacted Katie on what I considered to be short notice to make a Masonic lodge installation cake. I showed her pics of what I wanted it to look like. The day of installation I went to pick it up. I couldn’t believe what was on her counter. My cake. Exactly the layout I wanted but it looked a hundred times better than the original pics I showed her. At the installation nobody knew it was actually a cake and was amazed at the detail. I’m definitely using Katie for any occasion in the future.

Bob M.
Oct. 2014
Our little guy’s first birthday cake was absolutely incredible. It truly was a piece of art! I could not have imagined having such an amazing cake for our special boy. Katie put so much detail into his birthday cake that it was one of a kind. From start to finish, she was so excited about making a cake for our birthday boy. She was always quick to respond, knew exactly what we wanted and MORE! Her and her husband are both incredibly nice and went above and beyond for our son’s birthday. The cake tasted just as incredible as it looked and our guests couldn’t believe their eyes when they walked in and saw the cake on the table. I can honestly say, that I am already thinking about next years birthday and what type of cake she will be able to come up with for Wes’ second birthday party. Katie is an artist and has a passion for what she does and it shows in the final product. Hands down, the best cake in the Southeast Missouri area. -Kate Jackson, MO

Kate B.
May 2014
Hi Katie, We just got back from our honeymoon and wanted to make sure you knew how happy we were with our beautiful cake and cupcakes! Not only were they beautiful, but as we knew they would be, they were yummy! We are just so thrilled to have met you and will pass along your name and wonderful service you provide. Thank you so much!

Colleen and Dino
July 2014
Not only was the cake for my daughters 1st birthday beyond beautiful and fit for the little princess, everyone loved the delicious flavors we had chosen as well! This was my second time using Fancy that Cake for both my girls 1st birthdays, I wouldn’t use anyone else… Not only for the amazing artistic work done to the cakes, but because of the wonderful fun experience I had in the process of planning with Katie, down to matching the cake to my daughters dress! She is so sweet and never disappoints! Thank you so much for your amazing talent!

Brittni B.
Jan. 2015
Katie — Wanted to send you a big THANK YOU! The cake looked absolutely amazing and tasted even better. Even the photographer said it was by far the most beautiful cake she had ever seen! Thank you so much for making it such a stress-free display of such beautiful work!

Heather H.
Jan. 2014
Fancy That Cake did an awesome job for our daughters wedding reception this past June 2013! We were 100% pleased with everything! The service to us, the commitment, and the cakes not only tasted wonderful they were beautiful and just what we ordered! I recommend Fancy That Cake if you want the best!

Gretchen M.
Jan. 2014
Katie, The cake was a HUGE hit!!! Several ppl took business cards!! Almost all of it got eaten!! Everyone was very pleased!! It was absolutely delicious!! Thank u so much for a job Very well done!!

Lindsey K.
June 2011
Katie, The cake was beautiful!!! Kaitlin and Garrett loved it. Kaitlin and I both think that Grandma Glenna would have approved. We ended up with about 10 people serving it. We took it apart and took it to the back and cut it. We put labels on each tray indicating what kind it was and people loved it. Of course I will get pictures for you. If you ever want to use me for a reference, please do. I am somewhat picky and apparently so are you because I thought it was beautiful. Thank you so much for giving her a cake like my mom would have.

Cheri V.
Sept. 2012
Hi Katie, I want to thank you for doing such a tremendous job on both cakes. I was blown away at the attention to detail and the fact that both were the most delicious cakes I’ve ever eaten (and I’m a cake girl) was the icing on top. Even the Rice Krispy grill items were out of this world. You were so accommodating through the whole thing and I appreciate the prompt modifications you made. I see great things in your future. All of my guests wanted to know who made my cakes and I have nothing but the best recommendation to give for you. Thank you again for your excellence. I’ll be contacting you in a year for our anniversary cake!!

Caroline G.
Sept. 2013
Dear Katie, We loved the cakes! Thank you so much for all your hard work. Josh was very very pleased with his groom’s cake, and they both looked and tasted fantastic. It was a beautiful day and we had a great time. I don’t think I could have asked for anything better. Thank you so much for the advice. I will definitely take it to heart as we start our life together. Thanks again, Katie. You are wonderful!

Sarah G.
Oct. 2011
We are so glad you & your family were able to join us for our special day and I want to say how awesome your cakes are. They were above & beyond our expectations! And Scott was most excited about his groom cake. I tried all the flavors except our top tiers of course. The flavors were the best I’ve ever eaten! We will definitely recommend your services to anyone & everyone for their cake needs!Thank you so much for making our special day the best ever!

Crystal R.
July 2014
Everyone loved the cake and not only said it looked amazing but tasted delicious!! Thanks so much for making Matthew’s birthday so special!! I told everyone about you and to check out your website!

Caroline A.
Jan. 2014

Want to join the club and experience these awesome results our previous customers have had?

All you need to do is buy a (Fancy That Cake) cake! You will not be disappointed, our quality and service are top notch!

Our cake was amazing!! Everyone just raved about it!! It tasted so good, well except for the part that went up my nose ;).

Stef and Erik

I wanted to let you know that the cakes were perfect. The cookie cake was the highlight of our day especially. Brandon loved it. Was 100% surprised about it being her. It was so realistic our guests thought it was a statue. I didn’t cry the entire day till later in the evening when we kinda got a moment alone to look at her. It was perfect! Thank you so much for helping make my day absolutely perfect.

Danielle S.

I wanted to thank you again for doing such an amazing job on our wedding cake! Every last piece (except the top tier which was saved) was devoured! People are still raving about it!

Jennifer D.

We absolutely loved the cakes!!! Everyone talked about all the amazing flavors and of course the tractor! I can not thank you enough!!

Emily W.

Your cake was a hit! You may have seen it as one of the prominent pictures from the event in the SEMissourian. We displayed it out where the event was and it was an eye-catching centerpiece to our evening. Your stack of business cards were gone in 10 minutes. People were on their hands and knees looking up under the portico and up close at the authors written on the side. The more we looked, the more impressive your attention to detail became. And to top it all off, it tasted great. We cut 1″ square columns and went through maybe 2/3 of the cake that night. Rest was cut and boxed and put in the fridge in breakroom. It was all gone this morning! Thanks again for squeezing us in and making this very cool cake which became a focal point of our evening celebration. (Dec. 2014)

Dave S.

Hi Katie, I’ve been meaning to email you, so I apologize for the delay. I just want to thank you so very much for our beautiful wedding cake! It looked exactly how I imagined and how I wanted. It also tasted wonderful, and we received many compliments from the guests. We are so happy we saved our top tier, and we are still enjoying it! We decided to eat it while it is fresh rather than freeze it for a year in our tiny freezer, lol. I just wanted to let you know how much I appreciate your hard work and artistry. Thank you for the best wedding cake I could have ever asked for!

Amanda P.

Thank you so much Katie! David and I were more than happy and absolutely LOVED our cake!!!!! You did an AMAZING job on it!!! No one else could have done what you did!! Definitely recommended!!! I left your place knowing it would be absolutely perfect, and it was just that!!!!

Leah L.

Hi Katie, I know it’s been almost 2 months now since my wedding, but I was thinking about it and I never told you thank you! I just wanted to let you know that I absolutely loved my cake! It was beautiful and so tasty and it couldn’t have been more perfect! Thank you so much again!!! It was a perfect day!

Coleen G.

Hey Katie, I want to tell you how amazing the cakes turned out for the wedding. Everyone in my family is still talking about how real Trent’s cake looked. Thank you so much for all you did.

Amanda N.

My daughter’s Minas Tirith cake belonged on TV ‘s Cake Boss. It was totally amazing. And once we worked up the nerve to cut it, it tasted wonderful also.

Debbie G.