Welcome To Fancy That Cake

Southeast Missouri’s source for amazing, artistic, mouth-watering custom cakes!

Fancy That Cake


has been making custom cakes in the Tristate area since 2009…

...and we have had the privilege


and honor of making beautiful and delicious wedding cakes for over 400 area weddings!

Whether you are planning

a show-stopping, jaw-dropping, spare-no-expense, glitter-and-glam wedding reception worthy of a Hollywood starlet…

... Or you have your heart


set on a simple, rustic, country-style wedding, with a down-home feel and an imtimate atmosphere…

... whether you are


glitter-and-gold, ruffles-and-roses…

Cake Cutting

Who is going to cut the cake? You want everything to be “perfect” right? Fancy That Cake will professionally cut your cake for a small fee if you like. Limited to availability and a 30 mile radius. See FAQ secion for details.

Cake Sketches

An often overlooked free service offered here at Fancy That Cake is cake sketches. Katie will if requested (OR if needed) will sketch up your cake in PhotoShop to get your approval well before your BIG day!

Cake Tasting

Cake tasting have been a tradition for way longer than Fancy That Cake has been making yummy cakes. An excellent way for us to get to know the bride and groom and to help pick flavors when you just can’t decide!

Blush and Gold Topsy-Turvy Wedding Cake

The perfect wedding, the perfect day, the perfect cake

We know you want your wedding to have all the perfect pieces. Let us make sure your wedding cake will be just… well… “perfect!”

Super Cake Lady
  • Katie Goodpasture – Professional Cake Artist

    Katie didn’t begin as a baker who learned to create amazing cakes. Katie has always been an artist who simply learned to bake a delicious cake. There is a lot to be said for that! GOD gave her what she needed most, and she likes every cake to be a challenge. Her greatest payment is what any artist wants, and that is for you to love her art! And something else about Katie is she doesn’t quit until it looks “right.” And I promise your cake is gonna taste at least as good as it looks as well! Call Katie today and as she often says “Let’s Talk Cake” !

We absolutely loved the cakes!!! Everyone talked about all the amazing flavors and of course the tractor! I cannot thank you enough!!

Jennifer D.

Hi Katie, I know it’s been almost 2 months now since my wedding, but I was thinking about it and I never told you thank you! I just wanted to let you know that I absolutely loved my cake! It was beautiful and so tasty and it couldn’t have been more perfect! Thank you so much again!!! It was a perfect day!

Leah L.

We are so glad you & your family were able to join us for our special day and I want to say how awesome your cakes are. They were above & beyond our expectations! And Scott was most excited about his groom cake. I tried all the flavors except our top tiers of course. The flavors were the best I’ve ever eaten! We will definitely recommend your services to anyone & everyone for their cake needs! Thank you so much for making our special day the best ever!

Sarah G.

Like What You See?